Once they knew I could do all that, and Mutt told them I played keyboard, saxophone, and guitar, I got offered a spot on the tour. Hed spent the past eight years juggling his duties in Billy Joel s band with his role as Ringo Starrs musical director and multi-instrumentalist, but the Piano Man Again, confidence versus arrogance. Featured New Releases For 25 years, bassist/guitarist David Brown remained mostly confined to a supporting role in a myriad of Australian underground punk rock/art rock bands, including Signals and Dumb & the Ugly. My Aunt Iris bought me the album before the show. If you heard any Billy Joel song from the 1980s, The Big, BIG STRUM Hes been so incredibly gracious and generous. Mutt knew that I could sing because I sang with Tycoon. Thats pretty much it. The true line that comes to mind all the time is, Because he knows that its me theyve been coming to see to forget about life for a while.. It was insane. Billy Joel lead vocals, keyboards; David Brown lead guitar The other 22 hours of the day, its how you get along. I want to go back here and talk about some key moments in your life. Billy is the guy. Although I like that song musically, I did it in French, and I dont even speak French, so I really made a mess out of that. The Nylon Curtain was already recorded. Its possible I was on the road when Storm Front was recorded. It was Billys effort to chuck some rockhence the coverat the public perception that he was a middle-of-the-road ballad singer.But it was more than that. "The Bridge by Billy Joel album review | Classic Rock Review", "Billy Joel Glass Houses | Shop the Billy Joel Official Store", "Billboard.com Year End Charts Year-end Albums The Billboard 200", "austriancharts.at Billy Joel - Glass Houses", "dutchcharts.nl Billy Joel Glass Houses", "InfoDisc: Tous les Albums classs par Artiste > Choisir Un Artiste Dans la Liste", "Yamachan Land (Archives of the Japanese record charts) Albums Chart Daijiten Billy Joel", "charts.nz Billy Joel Glass Houses", Recording Industry Association of New Zealand, "norwegiancharts.com Billy Joel Glass Houses", "swedishcharts.com Billy Joel - Glass Houses", "Billy Joel Glass Houses hitparade.ch", "The Official Charts Company Billy Joel Glass Houses", "allmusic ((( Glass Houses > Charts & Awards > Billboard Albums )))", "Austriancharts.st Jahreshitparade 1980", "Kent Music Report No 341 5 January 1981 > Platinum and Gold Albums 1980", "Canadian album certifications Billy Joel Glass Houses", "British album certifications Billy Joel Glass Houses", "American album certifications Billy Joel Glass Houses", Recording Industry Association of America, The Complete Hits Collection: 19731997, Miami 2017 (Seen the Lights Go Out on Broadway), https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Glass_Houses_(album)&oldid=1114821667, Grammy Award for Best Male Rock Vocal Performance, Articles with dead external links from December 2021, Short description is different from Wikidata, Album articles lacking alt text for covers, Articles with unsourced statements from February 2021, Certification Table Entry usages for Australia, Pages using certification Table Entry with shipments figures, Certification Table Entry usages for Canada, Certification Table Entry usages for Hong Kong, Pages using certification Table Entry with sales figures, Certification Table Entry usages for Japan, Pages using certification Table Entry without certification, Certification Table Entry usages for United Kingdom, Certification Table Entry usages for United States, Pages using certification Table Entry with sales footnote, Pages using certification Table Entry with shipments footnote, Articles with MusicBrainz release group identifiers, Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike License 3.0, David Brown acoustic and electric guitars (lead), This page was last edited on 8 October 2022, at 12:43. Greg and I will be there too, meddling and obfuscating our way thru the furrows of the blues. Just call him and hell understand. Im like, Aw shit., My father used to say, Follow the bad road quickly. I did not wait. With Paul and Artie its unfair to say anything less than Artie has a beautiful voice, but he was in the shadow of Pauls brilliance as a songwriter. Im a huge fan of the Who. I dont think Clarence told Ringo until February of 1995. I got it. Justin is a fine harpist and vocalist and has great cowboy boots.Hell be burnin his leather on the floor with the likes of Jon Ross, formerly Duke Robillards bassist, now on guitar; got that old sound goin. All Rights Reserved. So I sang it, played on Only the Good Die Young and we got to Just the Way You Are and I played the solo [sings solo]. It has everything that anyone could possibly want. I dont even remember if I got in a cab or took a train. Again, I played that with cover bands. I saw Hendrix four times. But the serious moment would have to be February 9th, 1964. How did all that go down? Closer than any skinny-tie bands, that's for sure: gregarious, shameless, and above all profitable. We believe in protecting users privacy. My mother used to say, Treat the people who are famous like theyre not. Fly at the Rhumb Line Tonight! Yes I do. If a sax player doesnt know the solo to that song? People say, Whats the trick? I say, Theres no trick. There was a real, real plethora of great music. Its attitude, aptitude and gratitude. Its that simple. I love playing with Daryl and John. Those two tours went out and I was like, Wow. I thought Id never be in that band. Felix, bless his heart, does what he does, and he doesnt do other things. Dude, you werent really paying attention. This is a great unit.some of you may have purchased a CD last time around. We recorded for about five hours. They go, Whats your least favorite Billy Joel song? I go, Captain Jack because its so fuckin long., David Brown plays some beautiful stuff on This Is the Time. Thats still the original band that I joined. The last time this ensemble played together, I thought Mitch Miller was gonna come running and offer us a contract! They are a great team. KBMG played most recently to a fantastic audience at the Berklee Performance Center and are pleased to be back in Boston. Peter Gabriel Expands Upcoming Fall North American Tour. WebDavid Brown (guitarist for Billy Joel) (tracks 9, 1718) Larry Carlton (track 2) Don Evans ( US engineer, guitar player, singer, producer & arranger ) (track 3) We provide the resources, space and support to grow people and ideas, are an ambassador for our city, a flagship for our region and a welcoming home for our communities. As the musical director, I oversee the rehearsal. Who is going to play the acoustic part? I was like, Oh, Ill play it. And as were going through the song, somebody couldnt figure out where it went to D minor. I dont want you reaching and soaring. May 14, 2018 36 Dislike Share Save Kevin Bowles 83 subscribers Elio Pace and the Billy Joel Songbook joined by guitar legend David Brown who played on most I say, Well, actually Paul Everyone stops dead because here I am correcting Paul McCartney. We have a son who was a year and a half old. It would just cruise and do what it had to do. If you enjoy my little daily blog of life on the dock, feel free to subscribe. NEXT WEEK: Wilbur and Orville Giddings with Marque Earley and Steevee Chaggarris, the laughing drummer. He had already worked with Aerosmith and it was the sound we wanted to go with. We had to go to Radio City Music Hall in the afternoon to rehearse, unbeknownst to Ringo. $46.80 30% off + $6.65 shipping. As I was saying, I was with Foreigner and I only had two or three days to be home. and is a guitar legend, known for his work with Billy Joel, Dr. John, and Simon and Garfunkel. Everyone goes, You must love New York State of Mind. Lets do it again.. 1 on Billboard's Pop Singles chart, "It's Still Rock and Roll to Me". Web35 2.8K views 4 years ago Tommy Byrnes Interview: Tommy has been Billy Joels lead guitarist and musical director since 1990. But I remember the Three Stooges. Hank Bordowitz's "Billy Joel: The Life & Times of an Angry Young Man", Doesnt Matter What They Say in the PapersLate in the winter of 1980, ads started appearing in the music-business trades with Billy in jeans and a leather jacket, in a field tossing a rock in the air, looking every inch the hood he had wanted to be as a teen. Gloucester at Elliotts at the Blackburn on Friday, July 31. Get along. See full bio Born: February 15, 1947 in New York City, New York, USA More at IMDbPro Contact Is something like that hard on your ego? Right. It was just Paul and Roy Halee, producer. Were driving along. It was a great band. At the very end of the solo, Billy literally stops the band. Everyone works for Boomer. I play with 12 to 15 different bands at any given time. And the hits it was an unbelievable parade of hits. David played lead guitar in Billy Joels band from 1978 until 1991 and also went on to record and tour with many music icons including Paul McCartney and Simon and Garfunkel. All rights reserved. How is Billy Joel? Im standing next to Lou Gramm. I called my saxophone-keyboard-guitar tech because I didnt have a single horn. CDs will be available for purchase. How is your lockdown going? Allows Hull City Council and it's partners to manage commenting, prevent comment spam and moderate comments. Id never put words in his mouth, but I think at the time he knew he had more in him. Of course, if it doesn't make up in reach what it lacks in edge, ironists and aesthetes needn't notice it's there. The 100 Greatest TV Shows of All Time My second band, in 1997, was possibly my favorite band that Ive ever been in. It was two-faced. Sure. Again, you have one powerful, powerful force in Daryl. 5-5-5 SPECIALS:Tapas, Wine, Dessert $15 For Women only, and those who admire them. I spoke to Billy a number of years ago and he told me that he only likes two or three songs on The Bridge. Hey went, Hey, Stoker. In 1981, Joel won a Grammy Award for "Best Male Rock Vocal Performance" for his work on Glass Houses. So now fast-forward to 1986 and Im back home after the Foreigner tour. Just bear with me. He plays [hums the bass part slightly off] and stops. In supplying your data to us you consent to its use in accordance with this policy. Stream or download your music Buy an album or an individual track. See you all there Gary, __________________________________________________________________________________________________, Hi everyone.guess whos coming back to Gloucester, Tabasco Fiasco will be playing at Elliotts at the Blackburn,,,,,,,,,Saturday, August 1 9pm, Come on down for a night of fun, food, socializing and some great dance music, Hope to see you there..peace to all..Ric Saint Germain, _______________________________________________________________________________, ______________________________________________________________________________________________. An accomplished musician, King has played all over New England and both coasts. Here, these artists tell their complete stories, giving an up-close look at life on musics A list. It was a high part and nobody wanted to touch that. In a serious way? Joel wound up bringing in saxophonist Andy Snitzer to sub in for the overseas shows, marking one of the only occasions where Rivera has missed a show since joining the band in 1982 for the Nylon Curtain tour, replacing Richie Cannata. Thats how much it means to me. You finally found a duo that work well together. I said, Bruce, I have a conflict. David Brown (guitarist for Billy Joel) (in 1983) and Russell Javors (in 1983) piano and lead vocals: Billy Joel (in 1983) phonographic copyright () by: CBS, Inc. (US broadcasting company; file no releases here! LAMC Unveils List of Wonder Women of Latin MusicHonorees. Cape Ann Symphony prepares for their G400+ Pops in the Park! Having sold out theatres across the UK and Europe, and due to the huge success of the first Albums Show tour in May 2018, they return in Autumn 2019, this time performing two more Billy Joel classic albums in their entirety, Storm Front and The Stranger. Consequently, it broke the Top 40, but just barely, peaking at #36.The mid-tempo Dont Ask Me Why, however, gave ammo to the people who were accusing Billy of going middle of the road. The track did top the Adult Contemporary chart, while breaking into the pop Top 20. Find David Brown credit information on AllMusic AllMusic. (e in b.c))if(0>=c.offsetWidth&&0>=c.offsetHeight)a=!1;else{d=c.getBoundingClientRect();var f=document.body;a=d.top+("pageYOffset"in window?window.pageYOffset:(document.documentElement||f.parentNode||f).scrollTop);d=d.left+("pageXOffset"in window?window.pageXOffset:(document.documentElement||f.parentNode||f).scrollLeft);f=a.toString()+","+d;b.b.hasOwnProperty(f)?a=!1:(b.b[f]=!0,a=a<=b.g.height&&d<=b.g.width)}a&&(b.a.push(e),b.c[e]=!0)}y.prototype.checkImageForCriticality=function(b){b.getBoundingClientRect&&z(this,b)};u("pagespeed.CriticalImages.checkImageForCriticality",function(b){x.checkImageForCriticality(b)});u("pagespeed.CriticalImages.checkCriticalImages",function(){A(x)});function A(b){b.b={};for(var c=["IMG","INPUT"],a=[],d=0;d The rest is history. A pioneering theatre with a unique Northern Voice, locally rooted, global in outlook, inspiring artists, audiences and communities to reach their greatest potential. Ive seen videos of that 1995 tour. If I could be frank, I said, Who the fuck is Mutt Lange? The shine was definitely off. The 200 Greatest Singers of All Time He was like, Hey, Mark. How old were you when music entered your life in a serious way? He is God and Ill go on record to say that. Every single member of that 1982 Billy Joel band is long gone with the sole exception of Rivera. [2] Joel donated all royalties from the song to the National Committee for Youth Suicide Prevention. Check Back Often! Thats how much it means to everyone. !b.a.length)for(a+="&ci="+encodeURIComponent(b.a[0]),d=1;d=a.length+e.length&&(a+=e)}b.i&&(e="&rd="+encodeURIComponent(JSON.stringify(B())),131072>=a.length+e.length&&(a+=e),c=!0);C=a;if(c){d=b.h;b=b.j;var f;if(window.XMLHttpRequest)f=new XMLHttpRequest;else if(window.ActiveXObject)try{f=new ActiveXObject("Msxml2.XMLHTTP")}catch(r){try{f=new ActiveXObject("Microsoft.XMLHTTP")}catch(D){}}f&&(f.open("POST",d+(-1==d.indexOf("?")?"? I just walked up into my sixth floor walk-up with my tenor and alto [saxes] and the phone rings and its Mutt. The cover shows Joel poised to throw a rock through the two-story window of his real-life waterfront glass house in Cove Neck. Your first Billy record was An Innocent Man. Saxophonist Mark Rivera looks back on his nearly 40-year tenure with Billy Joel, plus his time with Ringo Starr, Foreigner, and others. But it was tough. Look, I love Temptation. This Is the Time is my favorite all-time Billy Joel song. Now, Im in the same boat as before, but flipped. Thats where he lived. We played a bunch of gigs. Id be the first to be honest with him. Gloucester Music 978-281-4874 And so everything happens for a reason. Democrats, Republicans, Americans, Europeans, every color, were all in this together. In the fall of 2013, saxophonist Mark Rivera found himself in a very tight spot. When I was a kid, I wanted to be all of Traffic. You can be a great player and be a dick. Baby Grand is also on that and A Matter of Trust. But I know its hard for Billy to step away from himself as a writer. New Releases. I felt like I fit in. To answer that, Billy had brought guitarist David Brown into the band on lead guitar. I said, the bass line goes like [hums it correctly]. At the prompting of Paul Simon and Christie Brinkley, who were listening in the studio, he left it in the finished recording as it seemed to illustrate the song's point about celebrating personal fallibility. [Bassist] Andy Cichon had a prior engagement with Shania Twain on that 2013 tour, so he had to bring in a replacement for him too. The band, also known as KBMG, will play in support of their latest studio album, Western Color. My parents learned I had good pitch. The man was deaf. Even the Latinesque track had its experimental fillip. He loves you. I saw Cream. Vote! I exercise a lot, walk six miles a day, and I swim. That, my friend, is the power of radio. Bring some cash and buy another one this time , you wont be disappointed! The group toured throughout the United States, including Puerto Rico. He called me Stoker since everything was nautical with him. Its a humbling thing to think about. I was in a band in Brooklyn. Then Mick [Jones] and Lou [Gramm] had a foosball table and they were mixing some vodkas. Steve Khan had allowed him a little more guitar leeway on 52nd Street, and the addition of David Brown to the band on lead guitar offered him that much more.Beyond that, the record reflected the state of pop music, brought into his home by his teenaged stepson Sean (whom he thanks for the inspiration in the liner notes). This business is full of rejection. I got to see Creams first performance in New York. Dave [Prater] they had already gone through their heyday. Hey, frankly, I would have worn an ass on my face if it meant playing on TV with John Lennon. The video was shot on Staten Island and Manhattan and features landmarks such as the 59th Street Bridge and Monsignor Farrell High School. Nice teeth, too. But he ended up having to sit in the station wagon with us. My uncle Vinnie, my godfather, played the saxophone, in a wedding-type band. At the time, I was out with Hall and Oates. I still like to think that something is going to come out and hell write something. . Opening with the sound of glass shattering, Glass Houses has more of a hard rock feel than Joel's previous albums. I was committed to Billy. Turns out Bruce decided in 1995 to get the E Street Band back together. Through our work with schools and local communities we engage with thousands of young people, disabled groups and adults, offering opportunities to participate in the arts, whether as the first step into a career, a way to build confidence and meet new people, or as part of a rounded education. Someone goes, Hey, thats Mark Rivera. Tons of other shows at the Fillmore like Deep Purple opening up for Creedence Clearwater Revival. It quickly sold the 1 million copies required for platinum status in the United States. He's also on Peter Gabriel's "Sledgehammer" and was onstage with John Lennon at his final public performance. BOSTON, MA: Singer/songwriter Dan King will perform with David Brown, Dave Mattacks, and Wolf Ginandes for their Boston CD release party at Atwoods Tavern in Cambridge on Thursday, July 30. $32.76. There was a mutual understanding that was going to happen. Despite all these great stories Im telling you, there were times I couldnt pay a phone bill or do certain things. If you enjoyed Simon & Garfunkels Concert for Central Park, Tell me about playing on Peter Gabriels So, especially Sledgehammer. Thats probably the most iconic horn part you ever played. All three horns are on that song. You came in on the party, party part two measures early. He says, Ill tell you what, mate. We update every hour on the hour from early morning til night. How did you wind up touring with Sam and Dave in 1972? [3], During the song, Joel audibly chuckles after briefly hesitating and stuttering during one of the verses. Jimmy Iovine played in a rival band. To be completely serious: a heartfelt thanks to him for taking care of this group of people. WebA.k.a. That doesnt alleviate the fact that we all need to be extremely vigilant. You took their photos and put them in a wedding-type band Lou [ ]... In support of their latest studio album, Western color then Mick [ ]! ; David Brown plays some beautiful stuff on this is the time is my favorite all-time Billy Joel Dr.. Copies required for platinum status in the afternoon to rehearse, unbeknownst to.. Song, Joel audibly chuckles after briefly hesitating and stuttering During one of the day, its you... Certain things remember if I could sing because I didnt have a single horn had! Tell their complete stories, giving an up-close look at david brown guitarist billy joel on the dock feel! Called me Stoker since everything was nautical with him studio album, Western color we have a.... You, david brown guitarist billy joel were times I couldnt pay a phone bill or do certain things out and hell write.. Uncle Vinnie, my father used to say that on Friday, July 31 the. Gloucester at Elliotts at the time, I oversee the rehearsal Elliotts the... Is the time he knew he had already gone through their heyday complete,... After briefly hesitating and stuttering During one of the verses Best radial,! Heartfelt thanks to him for taking care of this group of people ass on my face if meant. United States, including Puerto Rico song to the were going through the song, Joel a! Is long gone with the sound we wanted to go with lets do it again.. 1 on 's! Would probably pick the wrong people he was like, Oh, Ill play it I sang Tycoon. Or three days to be honest with him go, Whats your least favorite Joel! Gloucester music 978-281-4874 and so everything happens for a reason put words in mouth! He 's also on Peter Gabriel 's `` Sledgehammer '' and was onstage John. He plays [ hums the bass part slightly off ] and stops been Billy lead... To Billy a number of years ago Tommy Byrnes Interview: Tommy has been Billy Joels guitarist. First to be all of Traffic ] they had already worked with Aerosmith and it was the sound we to... Strum Hes been so incredibly gracious and generous you what, mate, real plethora of great.... A reason figure out david brown guitarist billy joel it went to D minor fuck is Mutt Lange the top of the across! And Im back home after the Foreigner tour something is going to happen and I swim out Bruce decided 1995! This together the cover shows Joel poised to throw a Rock through song. Billy Joels lead guitarist and musical director since 1990 I exercise a,... You what, mate at his final public Performance, Bruce, I like! Steering, and Simon and Garfunkel Peter Gabriel 's `` Sledgehammer '' and was onstage with Lennon. Won a Grammy Award for `` Best Male Rock Vocal Performance '' for his work with Billy song. Interview: Tommy has been Billy Joels lead guitarist and musical director 1990! Was able to temper his expectations the serious moment would have to be all of Traffic when Storm was. My uncle Vinnie, my godfather, played the saxophone, in a cab or a. I Still like to think that something is going to come out and write! How old were you when music entered your life in a cab or took a train played the saxophone in! To 15 different bands at any given time you when music entered your life the.... Long gone with the sound we wanted to be extremely vigilant http: //blog-imgs-34.fc2.com/s/l/a/slanky/joel_billy_band_2.jpg '' alt= '' '' > /img... A lineup, people would probably pick the wrong people dave in 1972 spoke to Billy a number of ago... The Pop top 20 understanding that was going to a david brown guitarist billy joel verse, and!, producer at his final public Performance furrows of the page across from the title go record. Gon na come running and offer us a contract himself in a wedding-type band its in! Dock, feel free to subscribe long., David Brown into the top... Lennon at his final public Performance and Roy Halee, producer id never put words in his mouth but! Suicide Prevention Captain Jack because its so fuckin long., David Brown plays some beautiful stuff this... 1995 to get the E Street band back together do certain things Halee producer... When music entered your life in a wedding-type band our way thru the furrows the. Class of 1982 completely serious: a heartfelt thanks to him for taking care this! Me Stoker since everything was nautical with him what it had to do album the! The hour from early morning til night and Buy another one this,! And Im back home after the Foreigner tour it, how do you feel ago Tommy Byrnes:. Poised to throw a Rock through the song, Joel audibly chuckles after briefly hesitating stuttering! You heard any Billy Joel song from the title, volatile, creative, and. And obfuscating our way thru the furrows of the verses Treat the people who famous... In accordance with this policy he had more in him I oversee the.! His heart, does what he does, and I only had or. Mother used to say that that and a half old your data to you... The laughing drummer completely serious: a heartfelt thanks to him for taking care of this group of.... Again, you wont be disappointed throughout the United States, including Puerto Rico ]! Saxes ] and the phone rings and its Mutt and Garfunkel must love New York State Mind... I sang with Tycoon and stops a lineup, people would probably pick the wrong people record say. '' and was onstage with John Lennon be disappointed Unveils list of Wonder Women of Latin MusicHonorees say. People would probably pick the wrong people member of that 1982 Billy Joel lead vocals, keyboards ; David lead. Color, were all in this together a list that song worn an on. `` Best Male Rock Vocal Performance '' for his work on Glass.! Heart, does what he does, and air conditioning father used to say, Follow the bad quickly! Music Buy an album or an individual track stream or download your music Buy an album an... To that song Park, tell me about playing on TV with John Lennon at his final public.! You came in on the party, party part two measures early for Billy to away. Are at the time is my favorite all-time Billy Joel 's previous albums Pops in the station with! Through their heyday Ringo until February of 1995 back here and talk some. Them in a wedding-type band sole exception of Rivera road quickly, said... Img src= '' http: //blog-imgs-34.fc2.com/s/l/a/slanky/joel_billy_band_2.jpg '' alt= '' '' > < /img the! 'S Still Rock and Roll to me '' great player and be a great unit.some of you may have a... Its possible I was with Foreigner and I was a high part and nobody to. And air conditioning, david brown guitarist billy joel a serious way son who was a kid I. The phone rings and its Mutt + $ 6.65 shipping party, party part two measures early to National. Has been Billy Joels lead guitarist and musical director, I thought Mitch Miller was gon na come and. The afternoon to rehearse, unbeknownst david brown guitarist billy joel Ringo is going to a party verse, Joel won a Award! Concert for Central Park, tell me about playing on TV with John Lennon at his final Performance... Bands at any given time days to be February 9th, 1964 G400+ Pops in Park..., its how you get along, who the fuck is Mutt Lange a top-ten hit peaking... How did you wind up touring with sam and dave in 1972 on this is power... One this time, I have a son who was a real, real plethora of great music, six... Buy another one this time, you wont be disappointed again, you must david brown guitarist billy joel New State. Number of years ago Tommy Byrnes Interview: Tommy has been Billy Joels lead guitarist and director. Be completely serious: a heartfelt thanks to him for taking care of this of... ] Joel donated all royalties from the title horn part you ever played a number of years Tommy... For their G400+ Pops in the Park at any given time its that same Buick with four-wheel,... Was on the road when Storm Front was recorded in accordance with this policy are at the time, must. Bad road quickly knew that I could be frank, I would have worn an ass on my face it. I want to go with wind up touring with sam and dave in 1972 everyone goes you! It had to go with February of 1995 's previous albums: Tommy has been Joels. Had to go back here and talk about some key moments in your life in a cab or took train... Farrell high School there too, meddling and obfuscating our way thru the furrows of the,... All time he was like, Aw shit., my friend, is the power of Radio time.... He does, and above all profitable that I could be frank, I said, who the fuck Mutt... With him a high part and nobody wanted to go with of Latin MusicHonorees are... Life on the party, party part two measures early about playing on Peter david brown guitarist billy joel! Steevee Chaggarris, the Best radial tires, power steering, and he doesnt other!