did beck cheat on joe with dr nicky

Beck earlier in the series had confessed to Joe she had an affair with Dr Nicky. When Joe realizes Beck knows the truth, he hits her over the head and holds her captive in the cage in the bookstore basement. What happened to Niall on Love Island UK? Unluckily for Beck, Joe stashed a key in the cage, so he gets out and - off-screen - kills her, then dumps her body and frames Dr Nicky for her murder. Romances . Later, Joe discovers that Beck actually did have an affair with Dr. Nicky and he decides to forgive . This line was spoken by George Burns in the TV show The George Burns and Gracie Allen Show. Beck Oliver is Jades boyfriend and has been with her for over two years, he is completely unafraid of her, and often likes to tease and make her. "The more you want me, the less I want you. Will Xbox Series X ever be in stock again? A woman wanders into his bookstore, and immediately Joe assesses her: What does that dress, that hoodie, those sunglasses have to say about who she is, underneath? It is later found out by Joe that the Dr. was having an affair with Beck and was very obsessive of her during their therapy sessions. Joe accuses Beck of cheating on him with Dr. Nicky and she denies it and then breaks up with Joe. Did Beck cheat on Joe with Dr. Nicky? I think he was looking for any evidence that he was wrong and when he found it, it was all he needed. 2022-07-02. Disclosure: Mathias Dpfner, CEO of Business Insider's parent company, Axel Springer, is a Netflix board member. Later, Joe discovers that Beck actually did have an affair with Dr. Nicky and he decides to forgive her. I could never love you. Upon discovering his affair with Beck, Joe contemplates killing him but decides not to do so. Beck makes her final appearance inside the glass cage after Joe kills Jasper, where she uncovers her scarf to reveal the marks Joe left while strangling her. But as Beck begs for Paco to let her out of the basement because Joe is a murderer who has killed people, Paco remembers that Joe is the person who killed his stepdad and saved his life. What he did not anticipate was that, shortly after the makeup sex and the exchanged I love yous, Beck would uncover exactly who her beau really is: her stalker, a murderer many times over, and a completely unhinged individual with a passion for that glass cage in the basement of his bookstore. Natalie. He shows how their relationship evolved, and how she slowly learned about the deaths of Peach and Benji. RELATED:You Season 2: 5 Characters Who Deserved So Much Better (& 5 Who Should Have Had It Worse). "I think we have some unfinished business to talk about.". One of the reasons for her familys move to the United States was that her parents raised her Jewish as much as they could. Starring Penn Badgley, Elizabeth Lail, Shay Mitchell, and John Stamos, the show's first season was filled with twists and turns and many characters didn't live to see the finale. But I'm confused on that. "Hey, bunny," Candace says to Joe, who is completely shocked to see her. Later, Joe discovers that Beck actually. Before he really knows her, he manages to find out enough about her to later getclose to her and manipulate her. She essentially guesses what kind of person Joe is based on their very few interactions. Hallucination Joe convinces Paco not to say anything. She tries to run away, however the main basement door is still locked. After knocking him out, Joe locked Benji in what some viewers have dubbed the "book dungeon," a glass box located in the basement of the bookstore that's intended purpose was to protect and temperature-control old books that needed to be kept in pristine condition. But no: Beck has an actual plan here. At one point during the season, Ethan refuses to tell Beck everything he knows about Candace's role in Joe's life. Birthplace When Beck reaches the top of the stairs, she finds its not just the cage that was locked, but the door to the basement, too. She also dies in the bookstore, not in the basement, where she was kept in the cage. This leaves more room for Joe to grow on his own and try to become a better person -a plan that isultimately botched, butit's a step in the right direction. He frames the murder as a suicide by typing a farewell note on Peach's computer. Its this essay that was published (with the help of Blythe) to great fanfare because if theres one thing that the world loves, its a good tragedy. Beck and Joe seem to get each other (or so Beck thinks) early on, but Love has work to do, and she's willing to do it. Though her faith may be misplaced, her consideration also shows that she can put Joe first and that she cares for and supports him. Joe later escapes the cage with his spare key and strangles Beck to her death before she can escape. Love seems to be very open and honest untilshe reveals her true self. Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment. WordPress Cookie Plugin by Real Cookie Banner. Love, all Love's friends, and Love and Forty's parents are very extreme versions. Later, Joe discovers that Beck actually did have an affair with Dr. Nicky and he decides to forgive her. But I was blinded by the story to put it together until the reveal. She unsuccessfully pleads with Paco to open the door but is soon abandoned by the latter due to his loyalty to Joe. Becks death in You Season 1 is shocking, but fans dont see the actual act. Who is the father of Scullys baby in The X-Files? Didn't you want him to crown you? Gil. Guinevere Beck was the object of Joe Goldberg's obsession in You Season 1. Does Freezing Peaches Change The Texture? Enemies One of the biggest moments of the season is when Joe seemingly kills Beck, which only ups his body count that also consists of characters like Peach, Benji, and Ron. Beck tricks Joe into coming into the vault, although, She tries to hurt Marienne, inviting her to their house, but ultimately cant. 2022-03-29. Mr. Mooney often locked Joe in the bookstore's basement vault for days on end in a cruel attempt to teach him how to truly appreciate books. After listening to it for a few moments, he decides their relationship is professional and that Dr. Nicky is a good therapist who is helping Beck. Did Derek and Erika break up RHPC? Nr p dygnet r det billigast att tvtta? Although the Netflix series never showed Becks death, it did imply that she suffered the same fate as the books. In the break between what we saw in season two and season three starting in the show, whilst Love is pregnant, Joe is arrested. Perhaps this means that Love and Joe deserve each other, but it certainly doesn't mean they're good people. Say you love him. While Joe and Love are alike in their nature, they don't share many interests. But only I can do that. Later, when Joe is in a relationship with Love Quinn, her brother Forty visits Dr. Nicky in prison. After years of relocation, Svetlana Sterlin (she/her) was raised by her Russian parents in Brisbane, Australia, where she completed a BFA and contributes to ScreenRant and Our Culture Magazine. He told Dr. Nicky that he was gay and struggling in his relationship, but he was really trying to see if Beck was sleeping with the therapist. Avan Jogia; Gender: Male: At the beginning of You'ssecond season, it's clear that Love isa more confident, more charismatic, and, most importantly, more open of a person than Beck was. Beck and Dr. Nicky Maybe not 100%, but you can tell that she's actually been cheating on Joe with Dr. Nicky when Beck tells him her session ran overtime compared to Dr. Nicky cutting Joe's session off right on the hour, even though they were deep in conversation. What year was the George Burns and Gracie show? Joe has experience in this cage. Did Becky cheat on Joe? The series is based on several books written by Caroline Kepnes. Overall, Love Quinn has directly murdered five people. Upon discovering his affair with Beck, Joe contemplates . The last time we see Dr. Nicky is when he's getting arrested. Actually, after several therapy sessions with the two characters, Dr. Nicky helps Joe and Beck unwittingly to mend their relationship and reconcile. If prince charming was real, he could save you from the unfairness of everything. and Joe's therapist-slash-mark upon whom he framed Beck's murder. When Joe goes to Claudias hospital bed to demand that she end things with Ron for Pacos sake, Claudia tells Joe that the only reason shes with Ron is because, as a probation officer, he has connections who would happily remove Paco from Claudias home should Claudia ever leave her abusive partner. When Joe begins a relationship with Karen Minty, Beck becomes jealous and regrets ending things with him. As an Angeleno, Ill be buying my books from Amazon. Paco is unsuccessful and just as Ron is about to go after Paco, Joe appears and kills Ron. What if you can't love him back? It does happen in my experience. Its horrific, of course the realization that the man she proclaimed to love less than 24 hours ago is now her captor but whats more disturbing is that Joe is convinced he and Beck still belong together. Last week on You, Joe (Penn Badgley) forgave Beck (Elizabeth Lail) for cheating on him with Dr. Nicky (John Stamos). Say thank you. Viewers probably thought Beck was on her way to safety when she cleverly used a typewriter key to stab Joe, steal the keys, and lock Joe in the cage. Top editors give you the stories you want delivered right to your inbox each weekday. Beck first meets Joe in Pilot, after she visits the bookstore that he works at. These are: Unfortunately for them, this is Love and Joe theyre up against and the pair get the upper hand making it look as though. The intense questioning reveals her clear mistrust of Joe, as well as her insecurities that she will never be good enough for true love. 13 Did Beck cheat on Joe with Dr Nicky? Find more from Svetlana here: https://linktr.ee/svetlanasterlin. Victoria Justice and Avan Jogia starred in The Outcasts as love interests, and it was suggested that Beck had been harbouring romantic feelings for Tori. Unluckily for Beck, The character of Joes young neighbor Paco (Luca Padovan) also became an important ingredient in raising the stakes for Joe. All season long, Joe tried to . It's revealed later that Joe still visits Mr. Mooney, who is now disabled and unable to speak Joe tells Beck that this is because he had a stroke. Not just any donut, but exactly the kind that Joe likes. Beck offers it to Joe as an escape route, but its all a ruse she just wanted him to let her out, so she could lock him in the cage and call the police. "Do you feel like you're pushing a good thing away? I haven't dealt with the shit that went on with me and Peach. The couple ended their relationship in The Worst Couple but got back together . This included finding him overdosed with a needle in his arm when she was 12 years old. Becks not sold (duh) but Joe doesnt really give her a choice. But I couldn't bring myself to get rid of it. The Lifetime-turned-Netflix series "You" is returning for a second season on December 26. What happens to Paco in You? Joe is flabbergasted did Beck seriously just throw Dr. Nicky in his face? Does Paco come back in You? Hopefully we'll find out the truth of Joe's past with Candace when season two of the series premieres on Netflix on December 26. She breaks up with him and decides to focus on working on herself and her writing. Beck had typed up all of Joe's crimes while she was locked up and she framed them as things her therapist had done, claiming he was obsessed with her. Later, Joe discovers that Beck actually did have an affair with Dr. Nicky and he decides to forgive her. Toward the end of the season, Beck discovers a box of disturbing evidence in Joe's apartment that alludes to his crimes and creepy stalker behavior. How do you know when gammon steaks is cooked? He stalks her, engineers situations for them to keep meeting, and eventually begins dating her. Mr. Mooney (Mark Blum) used it to teach Joe a lesson time and time again. He shows how their relationship evolved, and how she slowly learned about the deaths of Peach and Benji. She revealed in the past that the entire Roberts-Moder family went to a temple together to worship and celebrate. Throughout the season, Candace had been discussed at length as Joe's ex-girlfriend who ran off to Italy after things didn't end well between them. There were rumors that she might show up in the second season. December 3 He later ends things with Karen and he and Beck reconcile. Relationships By clicking Sign up, you agree to receive marketing emails from Insider RELATED:Netflix's YOU: 10 Pieces of Relationship Advice That Are Actually Solid. Later, Joe discovers that Beck actually did have an affair with Dr. Nicky and he decides to forgive her. He hears a clip from one session, and thinks nothing is going on?!? Did Beck cheat on Joe? Joe soon becomes her boyfriend and they have an up and down relationship. The discovery was disturbing, to say the least, particularly because she and Joe had just gotten over a major hurdle: After he found out that Beck had cheated on him with Dr. Nicky, her therapist . Later on in the apartment after arguing with Love, Joe sees her a second time, as she complains about why their relationship went wrong. Joe Goldberg (under the alias Paul), initiates his own therapy sessions with Dr. Nicky as a way to asses him and his possible influence on Beck. However, this doesn't mean that she is always a good person for Joe to be with. Natalies death is the first character death of the season, and it happens in episode 1 of season 3. As mentioned, Dr. Nicky is later blamed for all of Joe's crimes because of Beck's posthumously published false writings that blame her therapist. Why did they kill Beck in you? why did beck cheat on joe1990 donruss baseball cards errors. Love is adamant about getting to know Joe when she first meets him and takes him on a quest around the city to find his "perfect bite." What religion is Allen Jackson ministries? Nantucket, Massachusetts It is highly likely that Paco will feature in season two of You, given the dramatic ending of the final of season one. Portrayed by I can't understand why Beck cheats on Joe with dr. Nicky. Of course you think I'm hiding shit, I am. She's determined to get it right with him. . She went to Brown where she majored in literature. Viewers were shocked when Beck finally found everything in a box in Joe's bathroom: Benji's teeth, her old cell phone, other objects she thought she lost, and more. BeckRebecca (by Blythe)Beckish (by Peach)[1]Beckalicious (by Peach)Renaldo (by Joe to Dr. Nicky)Everythingship girl (by Karen Minty Picture: Netflix/Screenshot Joe looking at old photos of him and Beck on Instagram . How Old Is Beck Oliver now? They share a moment together in loving embrace until Beck uses it as an opportunity to turn the tables on Joe and lock him in the cage. Or perhaps NOT through Central Park given that Peach was assaulted there. Nickname(s) They dont write books about women like me, Claudia says bitterly and, since Joe lives his life by the written word, it causes us to realize just how little honest perspective weve really gotten in this story. Later, Joe follows Beck and Peach to the Salinger family's estate. I am hiding what a complete ugly mess I am, behind this cute acceptable version of being a mess. Throughout the season, Peach tries to get Beck to dump Joe while trying to get Beck to choose her over her boyfriend. Its via this story that we finally see some good writing from the MFA student (no offense, Beckalicious). We find out that she cheated on Joe with someone and that Joe pushed that person off of a balcony because of it. However, her feelings have been shown to be largely unrequited. Yes, he killed Benji (Lou Taylor Pucci) but Benji was a murderer who killed a kid during a frat party. Because her murder was never seen on screen, some fans are speculating that she's not actually dead. He believes he's gotten away with everything, having planted evidence in Dr. Nicky's yard to frame him for the murders, and believing he's made Beck's dream come true by doing . Her vocal range is from a low C3 to a high C6, and she really shines in her lower range and mid-range belts and head voice. Required fields are marked *. Unfortunately, the basement door is locked, and Joe catches Beck before she can escape. They did find that jar of pee Joe was so paranoid about leaving behind which must have been real weird for the cops on the scene. It also had Beck to fake her death, as she tries to escape Joe. There's also the case of Dr. Nicky, Beck's therapist-slash-fling (unethical!) The private detective investigating Peachs death doesnt buy Becks bullshit essay, and clearly has his eyes on Joe. Joe breaks up with his current girlfriend, Karen, who warns Beck to watch out for a girl named Candace, who was Joe's ex and still affects him a lot. The series stars Penn Badgley as Joe, a stalker who works in a bookstore. Benji was severely allergic to nuts. Joe's clingy and jealous behavior pushes Beck away, who tells him that if they don't have trust, they have nothing. Didn't put both those things together. Even before they're officially together, Love is highly committed to her relationship with Joe. When Joe finds out Beck and Dr. Nicky are having an affair, they break up and Joe starts seeing him for sessions under the. This is basically her love language, and it shows that she truly cares about Joe and wants to nourish him. When Paco later goes to the bookstore and finds Beck attempting to escape the basement, begging Paco to find the key and insisting that Joe is crazy and dangerous, Paco runs away leaving Beck to be murdered by Joe. When Beck locks Joe in the prison of Mr. Mooneys design, she gloats, telling Joe she would never, ever love him again. Beck posthumously becomes a best-selling author after her memoir is published by Joe, and her literary works are later sold at Joe's book store. Did George Foreman name all of his sons George? A hilarious and welcome addition to the very dark show, Ethan is Joe's friend and coworker who might know something about Joe's mysterious breakup with Candace. For a few episodes, Joe toys with Benji and he eventually kills himby giving him coffee with peanut oil in it, which causes a fatal allergic reaction. Love and Joe will be raising their baby in the suburbs, though Joe clearly sees Love in a different light now. They share a moment together in loving. Becks ghostly form appears, telling Joe, You hurt me. She takes off her scarf, revealing bruises all over her neck from Joe strangling her, and makes Joe look at what he did. Joe finds him to be insightful and continues to see him for more evaluation and advice, particularly about his relationship with Beck- although he changes names and situations so he does not realize who he is actually talking about. Later, when Beck is held captive in the basement, Paco hears her screams for help as she tells him through the locked basement door that Joe has "killed people.". It echoes Candaces (presumably last) words to Joe, who begged her not to leave him once upon a time. Beck loves Peach as her friend and consistently supports her but, for Peach, this is not enough. Although Karen and Joe are happy for a while, Joe runs into Beck at a food truck and they begin texting again. In the second season, Beck comes back as a hallucination. Didn't you ask for it? She warns Beck that Joe will likely cheat on her or worse. Beck is a kind and intelligent aspiring writer who meets Joe at the bookstore where he works and finds common ground with him as a fellow book lover[2]. In You Season 1, Joe Goldberg develops an obsession with MFA student Guinevere Beck. Here are five times Beck is either good or bad for Joe, and five times when Love is. As Joe hints at in his voiceover, Beck clearly wants attention, and herlackof curtains certainly proves his point. Dr. Nicky becomes the therapist of Guinevere Beck after the death of her friend, Peach Salinger. Did Beck cheat on Joe? For a long time, Peach has been in love with Beck, but her feelings have been largely unrequited. The character of Paco does not exist in the books You and Hidden Bodies and was purely created for the Netflix adaption, so really anything could happen. After knocking him out, Joe locked Benji in, Visit Insider's homepage for more stories, what some viewers have dubbed the "book dungeon,". Eventually Love realizes it isnt that shes not a good enough wife. After Joe kills her, he submits the writing to her publisher and frames Dr. Nicky for her murder. What Does An Overwatered Peach Tree Look Like? 2022-03-29. He shows Dr. Nicky a picture of Joe, and he confirms it was the patient he knew as Paul Brown. Adapted from a book series by Caroline Kepnes, "You" originally premiered on Lifetime, but it was picked up by Netflix and the streaming network is set to release a second season of the show on December 26. When Love reveals that she has known Joe's true nature all along and that she is just like him,he is just as shocked as viewers were. After Beck's death, Joe successfully manages to frame Dr. Nicky for all of the murders that he committed, including Beck. Since Paco didn't exist in the books, there was no one to help her to escape. A perfect fit. Beck has become a bestseller thanks to Joe, who secretly and happily takes credit for all her career successes, whether Beck was alive or dead. Joe recalls Candace's cheating on him with Elijah, whom Joe subsequently impulsively pushes to his death from a bridge after confronting . . Paco witnesses the murder and Joe convinces him not to tell anyone about it. It is later found out by Joe that the Dr. was having an affair with Beck and was very obsessive of her during their therapy sessions. After killing Beck, Joe frames Dr. Did Beck cheat on Joe with Nicky? Kepnes wrote a California-based sequel to You, titled Hidden Bodies, which will be the framework for the shows sophomore season. Beck seems to be the complete opposite to. It is later found out by Joe that the Dr. was having an affair with Beck and was very obsessive of her during their therapy sessions. Guinevere Beck Beck offers it to Joe as an escape route, but it's all a ruse - she just wanted him to let her out, so she could lock him in the cage and call the police. After Peach's death, things between Joe and Beck went sour. Beck starts seeing therapist Dr. Nicky after Peach's death. What was the plot twist in den of thieves? Benji Ashby. "I'm starting to think I'm some kind of magnet for likedudes with serious issues." After Joe murdered Beck, Dr. Nicky was arrested for the murder of Beck and he was suspected to have killed Peach and Benji. Edward Beck (father)Unnamed motherNancy Whitesell (step-mother)Mia Whitesell (step-sister)Cooper Whitesell (step-brother)unnamed half-siblingClyde (brother)Anya (sister)[1] She then went on to New York to get her Masters in Fine Arts. Compared to Beck's insecure and closed-off personality, Love's openness seems like a fresh and welcome change of pace for Joe. In one of her final moments, she tricks Joe and tries to escape the basement, but the door is locked. Written by Caroline Kepnes, it tells about a guy, Joe Goldberg, with a regular appearance but his behaviors tend to have Antisocial and Narcissistic Personality Disorders. How many movies has Daniel Craig done as Bond? What the f*ck is wrong with me?The book then continues similarly to the series, with Joe framing Dr. Nicky for Becks death. After numerous therapy sessions with both characters, Dr. Nicky unknowingly helps . OneTwo We then flashforward to four months after Becks death. Elizabeth Lail When the baseball bat fails to knock Ron out, Ron pursues Paco outside, threatening to kill him until Joe comes in. Friends Guinevere Beck and Love Quinn are almost opposites, yet Joebecomes obsessed with both of them. But every time I turn around you're standing there ready to make it all okay. Peach Salinger (stalker) Annika AttwaterLynn LieserBlytheRajPacoEthan Russell She was born and raised on Nantucket Island.[1]. Series Information Joe confronts Beck about sleeping with Dr Nicky 46,640 views Jan 2, 2020 379 Dislike Share Save David Lucas 75 subscribers One of my favorite scenes from season 1 of #You #Netflix. It's revealed that that woman is actually his ex-girlfriend, Candace, who was presumed to have been murdered by Joe and has now come to talk to him about "unfinished business.". The first season of the show was filled with murders, twists, and turns that kept viewers on the edge of their seats. How many quotes does Abraham Lincoln have? Dr. Nicky tells him that while he is innocent of killing Beck, he is guilty of destroying his family and using Beck as well as numerous others. Guinevere Beck was the object of Joe Goldbergs obsession in You Season 1. . When Beck unexpectedly came home early while Joe was still inside, he hid in the shower. As mentioned, Dr. Nicky is later blamed for all of Joe's crimes because of Beck's posthumously published false writings that blame her therapist. If Pedretti had landed the role of Beck, she would have been limited to only one season of the You. Throughout season one we learn through flashbacks that Joe was raised by Mr. Mooney, his boss at the bookstore. Both are mementos! Love uses the bottle to slit Candaces throat. Big mistake. Marienne takes the adviceeven encouraging Love to also run from Joeand leaves Madre Linda, changing her phone number. He also uses this logic to wave away the more terrible accusations against him. Its that Joe is a terrible husband. Does this mean Joe believed he killed Candace, only to have failed? She also deals with her grief by beginning therapy with Dr. Nicky. It was time in this cage that fueled Joes passion for reading great works of literature. This included finding him overdosed with a needle in his arm when she was 12 years old. How do I know if eSIM is activated on my iPhone? When they were both calling to cancel their appointments and sounding happy (cause they were bangin') he is seen sitting on his chair smoking his cigar looking indifferent. So, in the books, he has already been caught. 'You' returns this month. Joe and Beck date on and off for a few months, but after Peach's death, they really connect and seem like they're in a good place (from Joe's perspective). Meet Dr. Nicky. Alive Does Baylor Scott and White random drug test? Did Beck cheat on Joe? Victorious Opposite Date (TV Episode 2012) is a movie. 2022-07-02 He pulls a gun on him and demands his cell phone, where he finds numerous pictures, texts, and phone calls confirming their affair and Dr. Nicky's apparent obsession with Beck. According to recent social media posts by Liz Gillies and Avan Jogia, Beck and Jade are now married and living in Becks trailer, due to their inability to afford a house with a child of their own. In the movie, it was revealed that Beck seemed to harbour romantic feelings for her, though for how long and how intensely it was ambiguous. How long does a guinea pig live as a pet? Last week on You, Joe (Penn Badgley) forgave Beck (Elizabeth Lail) for cheating on him with Dr. Nicky (John Stamos). Paco probably assumes she means Ron and he turns away, leaving Beck for dead. How do you turn a 4 in 1 crib into a toddler bed? And so, during one of Peach's runs through Central Park, Joe ran up behind her and bashed a large rock against her skull, knocking her to the ground and leaving her to bleed out. Joe accuses Beck of cheating on him with Dr. Nicky and she denies it and then breaks up with Joe. The answer is no, though Beck does an excellent job convincing Joe that she still does love him and understands exactly why he did what he did. Bluebeard's Castle (Alive)Just the Tip (hallucination)Love, Actually (flashback) She starts to dig into what happened to Candace, growing more concerned about her disappearance and confronts Joe with her suspicions. At that point, he gave a false name. You is one of the examples of a novel. She says she is in love with Joe like never before and is afraid to lose him. Vad gr man med sticklingar? Outraged by him, Joe lured Benji into the basement of his bookstore by pretending he was a reporter for New York Magazine who wanted to do a feature on Benji's soda startup. Before season two of "You" premieres on December 26, here's a refresher on where every character ended up by the end of season one. If Joe was any other person, maybe things would have worked out really well between them. Strangled by Joe Goldberg off screen Beck tricks Joe into coming into the vault, although Joe eventually escapes and kills Beck. Throughout their lives, Love Quinn (Victoria Pedretti) and Joe Goldberg (Penn Badgley) have murdered a whopping total of. Back in season one and the first book, Joe is stopped by a police officer during a car accident he has on the way to Peachs house. Karen tells Beck that she likely saved her from whatever had happened to his ex, Candace, and Beck becomes curious about her disappearance. Dr Nicky was Beck's attractive therapist in You season one. Did Beck cheat on Joe with Nicky?